Skip to main content

Historical Jesus Class - Discussion 2

Based on this week's reading, describe three ways in which Jesus acted in the expected role of a rabbi.

 


Three ways Jesus fit the bill as a rabbi would include the following:

1)    Jesus was called a rabbi in his lifetime, and his reported actions fit the definition. As the book points out on page 354 Jesus had the title applied to him in much of the early texts, and the use of the title was left in the texts post-Easter. The fact the text was not altered to say that Jesus had always been referred to as the Messiah or Christ indicates the probable accuracy of the use of the rabbi title within his lifetime. Also, a rabbi is defined on page 355 as being the Aramaic word for teacher. Regardless of what one believes about the divinity of Jesus, the historical life of the man is certainly focused on teaching. The entire ethic of the historical man was traveling and talking to people about life and a promised afterlife, and how to have a better one of both. And despite the fact the book explains that there was no particular test to pass to be considered a rabbi; that you were one if you were called one – it also points out the role of rabbis as advice-givers (pg 355 still). If that is not the perfect definition of the historical Jesus, I don’t know what is. Both asked for, and unsolicited advice, seem to be the focus of his every waking moment.

2)    Jesus clearly had the education of a rabbi. On pages 355 and 356 it discusses how Jesus would have had some religious education in the home as a young child, learning stories and memorizing them. And whether he attended an elementary school or simply his local synagogue he most certainly would have had some access to learning to read and write. The middle of page 356 contains a list full of hints/statements from the texts indicating Jesus was literate. Perhaps the most significant of these examples is the indication that Jesus regularly taught in synagogues, and a key feature would have been someone reading out scripture while the gathered listened. The book makes the solid point that Jesus probably wouldn’t have agreed to teach in such an environment if he were not also equipped to do the reading out, if invited to do so.

3)    Jesus was just trying to talk about a better way to live, not running a political revolution. He didn’t ask his followers to fight the power structure or refuse to pay taxes. He simply took the long-standing ethical instruction scattered throughout contemporary Judaism, stripped away the focus on rituals and distilled it into its clearest form possible – then shared it with anyone who would listen. As the book puts it on page 353, Jesus was “the concentration of the ethical message” which had gotten “dispersed and mixed in with ritualistic and other elements” by other rabbis. In this way he drilled down and focused on message and principle over ritual and law. His focus was on extrapolating the moral of a particular story or scriptural concept into real life (the role of a rabbi) not overthrowing the government (the role of a revolutionary).


Comments

Popular Previous Posts

The Ethics of Eating Meat - Animals and Society Class Discussion

Q: After reviewing the course materials for Weeks 6 and 7, discuss the concepts of moral equality and moral recognition. How do they impact the treatment of animals and people? What are the ethics of keeping animals in captivity and killing animals? How do animals become meat? How does the consumption of meat establish borders between classes, races and genders? What are some of the ethical questions surrounding the consumption of animals?  Photo by Christopher Carson on Unsplash A: Moral equality is the principle that all people have equal human rights – or that at least is the way it should be; the ideal. Moral recognition is the acknowledgement that there are differences between various groups of people (different genders, races, beliefs, behaviors, levels of intelligence, etc.), but the ideal of equality should still be applied; the differences should not merit different treatment.  However, this idealized equality – which we still struggle to apply to all people – is most defin

You Are a Badass at Making Money - Review

You Are a Badass at Making Money: Master the Mindset of Wealth by Jen Sincero My rating: 3 of 5 stars The book was more focused on my emotional relationship to money than I expected. There were some assumptions about those attitudes which I didn’t feel applied, so I didn’t feel as connected to this book as the previous Badass. But there were still some really good points and strong takeaways. It reminded me to own what I want. View all my reviews

Work From Home While You Roam - Review

WORK FROM HOME WHILE YOU ROAM: The Ultimate Guide to Jobs That Can Be Done From Anywhere by Robin Barrett My rating: 4 of 5 stars Excellent resource! I found out about this book by stumbling onto Robin Barrett’s YouTube channel. I saw a video in which she listed some interesting work from home options and decided the book was worth a try. It most definitely was. Despite doing my homework in looking for a new income stream there were still resources listed here that I didn’t already know about - and the explanations of the application processes and the payment methods saved me a lot of time in narrowing down the list to things I will actually pursue. There is a lot of repetition in the book - as there are sites which fall under more than one of the categories into which the book is organized. I read the entire book, but I would recommend that if other readers know which category they are most interested in, they just skip straight to that chapter to avoid the cross posting (for lack