Skip to main content

Places in Motion - Reading Response 2

Places in Motion: The Fluid Identities of Temples, Images, and Pilgrims by Jacob N. Kinnard.
Thoughts on Chapters 4 & 5

I was most struck this week by what Kinnard refers to as “the “museumizing” of the temple complex” (pg 119), especially via the UNESCO World Heritage Site determination process. The mentality of imaging there is an “original” state to which the otherwise “active and fluid place” of the “living temple” (pg 118) should be returned, and then subsequently frozen in time to be “preserved” like an insect in amber, is mind-boggling to me in relation to an active religious site. Even if it were a genuinely disused archaeological ruin, the idea of ‘returning’ it to some imagined original form could be problematic – but in light of the current usage of this site I cannot comprehend how altering what is there currently could be anything other than destructive to how it is being used.

I was particularly provoked by what Kinnard called “the ambiguities of preservation” (pg 142) since I can absolutely understand the impulse to not let culturally important places rot or disappear. However, he is right when he says that “[c]onservation and preservation … are not value-neutral activities” (pg 124). However well intended, it is a very ethically challenging concept for me to see a Western body like UNESCO waltz into a different culture (one which 100-200 years ago UN member nations would have had a colonial interest in) and declare anything “the property of the whole world” (pg 120). It smacks of a modern-day colonial ethos which should be more fully explored and questioned, especially in regard to execution. While the guiding principle of preservation might be helpful – ignorant implementation can do more harm than good.

And to attempt to ‘preserve’ an actively evolving religious site, without any intercultural understanding of the fact that without transformations like religious images being painted, clothed, or bejeweled “these gods “die” in so far as their devotees are concerned” seems doomed from the start. Since the various layers of the temple and the iconography are “both a record of prior use and part of current practice” for an entity like UNESCO to even suggest that non-original elements should be removed is, indeed, to “do violence to the character of the temple” (pg 135). To envision and define such a living place as a static archaeological site not only denies it’s “larger complex, messy history” (pg 136), but creates a fundamentally inaccurate view of it as a place ready for a museum display, “devoid of people” (pg 141), and kills the  place in order to preserve it (pg 142).


Comments

Popular Previous Posts

The Ethics of Eating Meat - Animals and Society Class Discussion

Q: After reviewing the course materials for Weeks 6 and 7, discuss the concepts of moral equality and moral recognition. How do they impact the treatment of animals and people? What are the ethics of keeping animals in captivity and killing animals? How do animals become meat? How does the consumption of meat establish borders between classes, races and genders? What are some of the ethical questions surrounding the consumption of animals?  Photo by Christopher Carson on Unsplash A: Moral equality is the principle that all people have equal human rights – or that at least is the way it should be; the ideal. Moral recognition is the acknowledgement that there are differences between various groups of people (different genders, races, beliefs, behaviors, levels of intelligence, etc.), but the ideal of equality should still be applied; the differences should not merit different treatment.  However, this idealized equality – which we still struggle to apply to all people – is most defin

You Are a Badass at Making Money - Review

You Are a Badass at Making Money: Master the Mindset of Wealth by Jen Sincero My rating: 3 of 5 stars The book was more focused on my emotional relationship to money than I expected. There were some assumptions about those attitudes which I didn’t feel applied, so I didn’t feel as connected to this book as the previous Badass. But there were still some really good points and strong takeaways. It reminded me to own what I want. View all my reviews

Work From Home While You Roam - Review

WORK FROM HOME WHILE YOU ROAM: The Ultimate Guide to Jobs That Can Be Done From Anywhere by Robin Barrett My rating: 4 of 5 stars Excellent resource! I found out about this book by stumbling onto Robin Barrett’s YouTube channel. I saw a video in which she listed some interesting work from home options and decided the book was worth a try. It most definitely was. Despite doing my homework in looking for a new income stream there were still resources listed here that I didn’t already know about - and the explanations of the application processes and the payment methods saved me a lot of time in narrowing down the list to things I will actually pursue. There is a lot of repetition in the book - as there are sites which fall under more than one of the categories into which the book is organized. I read the entire book, but I would recommend that if other readers know which category they are most interested in, they just skip straight to that chapter to avoid the cross posting (for lack